Showing posts with label favourite. Show all posts
Showing posts with label favourite. Show all posts

Sunday, 1 January 2017

Essential Doctor Who: First Doctor: The Dalek Invasion of Earth

Yes, I knew that I invited criticism by not including "The Daleks" as essential Doctor Who. Of course it is, but only in terms of the history of the series. I personally didn't rate it and didn't enjoy it much. This second dalek story, though, is a different kettle of fish altogether.

Produced on MS Paint using Bamboo graphics tablet
This is one of the Hartnell stories where I could honestly say that I knew the storyline pretty well before watching it. This is partly through having several times seen the Peter Cushing film, “Daleks : Invasion Earth 2050” based on the serial, and partly through the Target novelization. While the film to a greater extent, and the novels to a lesser extent may take a couple of liberties with some of the plot details, by and large they’re pretty faithful enough to give you a good idea.

After Watching

While not wishing to gloss over any of this show’s flaws, I really enjoyed it. I wrote about the DWM Mighty 200 poll in my round up of season 1 – and this story is ranked 44th on the DWM Mighty 200 poll, and I think that’s pretty fair.

Actually the start of the serial, the first episode, was really on the whole rather good. I mean, I’d already in the past watched “An Unearthly Child”, and “The Daleks”, and read the Target novelisation of “The Keys of Marinus”, but when you see the opening of this, their last adventure together, you come to realize how they have developed as a group together. You can’t help wondering what the impact of this episode would have been had they kept daleks out of the title, and pre publicity for the show, and you hadn’t realized they were involved until that iconic final shot of the dalek coming up out of the Thames.

Really and truly, this should be quite disorienting. I am watching this in 2015, pretending to be London some time after 2164, while all the time making no effort to look like anything other than 1964. Although the show is set around 2164, the visuals make no concession to this, and as a result you kind of just get on with it. If anything it gives the story a nostalgic feel.

Actually, the rather gentle pace of the first couple of episodes, and the atmosphere reminded me of films such as ‘Day of the Triffids’, and if anything its maybe a foreshadowing of Terry Nation’s own “Survivors”, his 1970s drama series about life for a group of survivors of a devastating pandemic which kills a huge percentage of the human population of Earth.

 I don’t know that you can get the point of the Hartnell shows from just reading the Target books. The stories I’ve actually seen, and this one in particular give me the strong feeling that you have to watch them to understand.  I loved the third and fourth Doctors, but there was always a feeling that they were going to eventually take charge and be more than equal to whatever situation they might find themselves in. The dynamic is completely different in the Hartnell era. In “An Unearthly Child” the Doctor has taken Barbara and Ian off on a joyride to prove to them that he can do what he says he can. This is an extremely irresponsible, if not reprehensible act, since he knows that there is no guarantee that he is ever going to be able to bring them back to his own time and space. In the first episode  they do actually believe that they’re home after all this time, and it’s the dawning realization that this is not actually the case which adds greatly to the atmosphere and poignancy. I find that the way that the action and the driving of the plot is shared out between the Doctor , Ian and Barbara, and to a much lesser extent Susan, to be really different to what I’m used to as well. It shouldn’t work, and yet it actually does. For example – the extended sequences of Barbara and Richard Briers’ wife running through the streets of London pushing Dortmun should really be laughable. But they aren’t.

Partly this is because of some great acting. Look at Jacqueline Hill’s face during these sequence. I tell you the woman looks terrified out of her skin. I cheered when she drove into the Daleks.

OK – the plot, essentially, is rubbish. The Daleks are excavating the Earth’s core in order to bung a motor in it and fly it around the Universe? Yeah, right. Nonsense. The special effects shots of the Daleks’ flying saucer actually flying are rather embarrassing. They must have looked pretty crappy even back in 1964, which is why you see so little of them. I can’t help wondering why they needed these shots anyway. If you’re going to do it that badly, then why do it at all? Then there’s the Robotmen. Their headsets are awful, and some of their acting doesn’t seem a lot better. Yet harping on about these things is all missing the point. I concede all of these drawbacks, and yet I loved it.

This story is all about the triumphant resurrection of the Daleks. They had a massive part to play in the success of the first season, and as a reward they get a story which allows us the iconic shots of the lone Dalek rising out of the Thames, and Daleks trundling across Westminster Bridge and around Trafalgar Square. The shots of the robotmen overseeing the enslaved humans dragging wagons into the mine are really good too.  There’s some lovely performances too. Bernard Kay – again, a name you might not know, but a face you surely do – is always good value for money. It was nice to see Nicholas Smith – Mr. Rumboldt from ‘Are You Being Served’ popping up in the mine scenes too. If you twist my arm and force me to tell the truth I’d admit that it’s probably at least an episode too long, and yet I would still far rather watch this than the film version any day of the week. I would also far rather watch this than ‘The Daleks’ .The original Dalek serial is too long at 7 episodes, and I’m afraid that the Thals get on my wick after a while, being, in my considered opinion, a bunch of big girls’ blouses. And if that wasn’t enough, we have Susan’s leaving scene. This is neatly prepared for with a couple of the Doctor’s comments as he notices the burgeoning romance between Susan and David Campbell. Actually, I say burgeoning, but this was 1964 family viewing, so subtle hints are all we get. The Doctor has been criticised for his indecent haste in packing Susan off at the first opportunity, but I think that this is in character, as a protracted leaving scene would not be something he could handle yet. This was the first ever leaving scene in Doctor Who, and in my view Hartnell pulls it off brilliantly. These little emotional moments, where he is called on to put out real tenderness, really show off what a good actor he was.

Judging by the fact that she was willing to appear in 1983’s ‘The Five Doctors’, and other appearances on various shows and DVDs about the show, Carole Ann Ford has come to terms with her time on the show. You can’t help sympathising with her, since by all accounts she was sold on the ‘unearthly child’ concept of her role, yet found that the unearthly aspects of her character were largely ignored, and she became the first in a long line of screamers. For a lot of her time she was just used as a functional character whose purpose was there to move the plot forward. She wouldn’t be the last. I am sorry to see her go, but I think the show will cope without her far more easily than it would do without Ian or Barbara at this stage.

 What Have We Learned

Everything is cyclical. Or, put it another way, London in 2164 will be a dead ringer for London 1964
William Hartnell is capable of scenes of genuine emotional intensity
Daleks keep pets

My Favourite Star Trek Original Series Episodes: Season 1 Balance of Terror


What’s it all about?

Ahhhhh. What’s not to like here? The Enterprise receives distress calls from outposts bordering the neutral zone between the Federation and Romulan space. Yes, folks, the Romulans, who would become the dominant enemy in the Star Trek Universe for a while after the Klingons had made peace with the Federation, did actually make their appearance before the Klingons.

The Romulans and the Federation were at war 100 years earlier. Amazingly, nobody has ever seen a Romulan, which does make me wonder hwo the Federation carried out peace negotiations in the first place. Still, it turns out that a Romulan bird of prey ship has been sent across the neutral zone to attack the outposts in order to gauge the relative strength of the Federation. If they are found to be weak, then the Romulans wil start war again. Kirk and the Enterprise track the Romulan ship, and decide that they must destroy it before it can enter the neutral zone. If they follow it into the neutral zone, then this would give the Romulans a pretext for declaring war. If the Romulan ship gets home with a favourable report, then war will happen anyway.

The Romulan ship only has impulse power, it does not possess a warp drive. However it has two advantages over the Enterprise. The weapon it carries is incredibly destructive. One good hit from that and the Enterprise would be destroyed Also, it has a cloaking device, that renders the ship invisible. Although strictly speaking this seems a bit pointless since the Enterprise seems to manage to track it even when it is invisible a lot of the time.

Complicating matters is the fact that, gawd knows how, but the Enterprise is able to get visual on the Romulan ship, and we see what appears to be nothing so much like a ship full of Vulcans. This enables a sub plot since helmsman of the week, Mr. Hansen, had family killed in the Romulan War, and he suspects Mr. Spock, and is frankly insubordinate, so much so that for my money it’s shocking that Kirk didn’t have him flogged amidships for his pains.

So what we get is a game of cat and mouse between two commanders – Kirk and the Romulan, who seem to be able to anticipate each other’s every move. And if that sounds a bit of a bore, well, it really, really isn’t. In fact, I don’t know if this was an influence on Gene Roddenberry and writer Paul Schneider at all, but it reminds me of a submarine movie starring Clark Gable and Burt Lancaster called “Run Silent, Run Deep”, because essentially that’s what the Romulan ship and the Enterprise are for this episode – the firing debris out to make it look like the Romulan ship has been destroyed is straight from that movie for example.

In the end one of the Romulan subordinates, who is close to the Romulan Praetor, presumably the ruler or a very high status official, threatens the captain to go in for the kill on the Enterprise, or he will be having words in high places when they get home. Thus he falls into the trap, and zap zap zap with the phasers, and the Romulan ship is disabled.

There’s a terrific climax, where, having offered to take aboard the Commander and his crew, Kirk has to watch as the commander refuses, telling him that this is not the Romulan way, and he adds, “You and I are of a kind. In a different reality, I could have called you friend.” Now, ok, this is the sort of thing that a couple of decades later Red Dwarf would decry as ‘all that Star Trek crap’ but I don’t care, I like that.

You Probably Already Know That: -

·       Mark Lenard, who played the Romulan Commander, would return in Season Two to play Spock’s father, Sarek. He also played General Urko, leader of the Gorillas, in the short-lived TV series version of “Planet of the Apes”.
·       In the UK during the 70s you could Aurora sold plastic self assembly model kits of the Enterprise, a Klingon Starship, and the Romulan War Bird. I bought and made the Enterprise. Today a second hand original kit, if you can find one, could cost you as much as a couple of hundred pounds.
·       The ‘cloaking device’ as it becomes called is one of those ideas which proved too good to just use in a one off episode. Later in the original series not only do the Klingons get the device from the Romulans, so does the Enterprise as well.
·       This is not the only example of “Star Trek” seemingly being influenced by the movie “Run Silent, Run Deep”. In “Star Trek: The Motion Picture”, the first movie, the relationship between Admiral Kirk, and the young Decker, whose command the Enterprise would have been  is extremely similar to the relationship between the Gable and Lancaster roles in the film.

The Verdict

You must have already gathered that my feelings about this particular story are almost completely positive. Almost? Well, yes, we can always criticize. The frame of the story is that right at the start in the pre titles sequence, Kirk, as Captain, is presiding at an on board wedding, between crew members Angela Martine and Robert Tmlinson. Before we get to the do you – I do – she does business, the attack starts, so they are not yet actually married. During the fight with the Romulans, sadly Tomlinson gets killed. At the end Kirk, quite rightly, has to go to talk to Martine, and comments that some times none of it makes any sense. I want to yell at the telly – fine! Stop it there! That’s enough! Sadly it goes on to have Angela Martine looking up bravely at Kirk, smiling through her tears, and telling him she is alright, and it’ alright. Arrgggghhhh! Still, it could be worse. Kirk might have invited her back to his quarters for a wee dram.

That aside, I my opinion it really doesn’t get a lot better than “Balance of Terror”. Watch it and you’ll understand why they wanted to find a way to bring Mark Lenard back in as similar a role as possible – he’s great.

Friday, 23 December 2016

My Favourite Star Trek Original Series episodes: Season 2: Episode 1: Amok Time


Amok Time


What’s It All About?


So here we are, season 2, and it starts with one of THE iconic Star Trek original series episodes. The focus on Spock is probably a reflection of the production team’s awareness of the popularity of Spock throughout the first season, and generally episodes which foreground Spock are often better than episodes that don’t.

With each episode having little more than 50 minutes actual ‘story’ time as such, once you’ve accounted for ad breaks and opening and closing titles, when you’ve got a real story it can be difficult to make sure that you cram the whole story in. This may be the reason why “Amok Time” has such a relatively abrupt start. If you had all the time in the world then you could very slowly build up what is happening to Spock. We don’t have that luxury, so right from the pre-title sequence Spock is behaving oddly and causing concern. One of the tell-tale signs is the fact that Nurse Chappell makes him some Vulcan plomeek soup, which he throws all over the walls. Later on in the episode McCoy sardonically observes to her – you never give up, do you?! – No, matey she doesn’t, and she’ll still be around in the franchise after you’ve hung up your stethoscope.  

Spock requests the ship divert to Vulcan, and give him shore leave, but he will not tell Kirk why it is so urgent for him. Kirk agrees, but then a request for StarFleet for the Enterprise to take part in some ceremony in Altair 6 comes through. Spock changes the course back to Vulcan, and cannot explain to Kirk why he has done it, in fact, he wasn’t even aware that he had done it. Finally, in his quarters, he explains to Kirk what it’s all about. 

Here we get a healthy slice of new Vulcan lore – and also some of the worst dialogue which poor old William Shatner was ever given to say as Kirk.  Spock tells him that it is the Pon Farr, but finds it difficult to cut to the chase. So we get: -
“It is to do with biology.”
“Biology?”
“Biology.”
“Vulcan biology?”
“Yes.”
“The biology of Vulcans?”

I mean, how thick is Kirk in this scene? I have to say, though, I do like it when Spock turns to Kirk and asks how he imagines Vulcans mate, and he choose his words, saying that he imagines that they do it . . . logically. Of course, the whole point of the story is that they don’t. They go crazy – well, I’ll be honest, you’ll see worse outside any town centre pub on a Friday night, but it’s as crazy as you can expect a Vulcan to get. When the Pon Farr comes on them, they either mate . . . or die. After trying his luck with the Admiral who told him to divert to Altair VI, Kirk mutinies, and goes to Vulcan to save his best bud. Spock asks Kirk and McCoy to accompany him to the ceremony, which upsets the Vulcan matriarch T’Pau, but is actually permitted, providing that they never speak of what they see. Right, at this point I have to speak of T’Pau. This is childish of me, but I couldn’t quite get over her rather heavy central European accent. Rather less childishly, I found myself exceptionally irritated by her continual and incorrect use of the word ‘thee’. What follows is a short grammar lesson, so please feel free to look down to the next paragraph. Basically, ‘thee’ is the object form of the archaic word ‘thou’ which means ‘you’. So you can grammatically say : -
I will marry thee
I will give my word to thee
I have heard good things of thee.
What you CANNOT do is use it as the subject of a verb. So you can’t say –
Thee has agreed to marry T’Pring.
You have to say Thou.
Ah yes, Dave – you may well be saying – but this is Vulcan. Surely they can use thee how they like. I accept that you can have this point of view, yes, but the trouble is it sounds like cod-Shakespearian dialogue done extremely badly, and it detracts from what is going on. Especially when bloody Spock starts doing it as well!

So, Spock’s intended, T’Pring makes a challenge to stop the ceremony going ahead, as is her right. She likes Stonn, who will be a lot easier to dominate than Spock will. Their plan is for Stonn to challenge Spock, but that goes out of the window, when she picks Kirk. Her thinking is that if Spock kills Kirk, he won’t want her because he will be so mortified, and if Kirk kills Spock, Kirk won’t want her. Either way, she wins. Kirk makes the schoolboy error of not actually asking the details of the combat. So, after he agrees, he gives a great double take as T’Pau observes as she passes on her way out – “This combat is to de dett.” If you don’t speak Vulcan, well it means a fight to the death.

You know what happens I’m sure – wily old McCoy asks permission to give Kirk an injection to combat the effects of the heat and the thin atmosphere, and then slips Kirk a mickey finn. As soon as it takes effect he announces that Kirk is dead, and has him beamed up to the Enterprise before anyone notices that he’s still breathing. Spock interrogates T’Pring, and gives her the freedom to marry Stonn, warning him that wanting is not the same as having. Good line.

Not quite over yet, Spock presents himself to McCoy on the Enterprise, ordering him to lock him up for murdering Kirk, then has about half a second’s unrestrained joy as Kirk appears from the doorway behind him. Ahhhhhh.

You Probably Already Know That: -


·       This was scripted by Theodore Sturgeon. Theodore ‘Ted’ Sturgeon was among the first rank of American Science Fiction writers of the middle of the 20th century, and award winning writer of a large number of short stories and successful novels

·       The Vulcan matriarch presiding over the ceremony is called T’Pau. Her name was used by a British 1980s band fronted by singer Carol Decker. Although their success was shortlived they scored a massive hit with the single “China In Your Hand”.

·       Pavel Chekov, played by Walter Koenig, makes his first appearance in this story. The youngest member of the regular cast, Koenig was hired to appeal to younger female viewers, hence the Beatle/Monkee haircut. For his first few stories until his own hair grew long enough he was forced to wear a ‘monkees’ wig, which he hated. To be fair he does look ridiculous in it.

·       Gerald Fried’s piece of iconic incidental music played during the fight scene became the standard piece of Star Trek hand to hand fight music. It has been used in a number of parodies, including scenes in Futurama and films such as Jim Carrey’s “The Cable Guy”

·       Celia Lovsky, the Austrian American actress who played T’Pau, made her final screen appearance in the sci fi film “Soylent Green”, which incidentally also saw the last screen appearance of Edward G. Robinson.

·       Lawrence Montaigne, who plays Stonn was seen in the series 1 episode “Balance of Terror” playing the Romulan second in command. He’s in good company. Mark Lenard, who played the Romulan commander in “Balance of Terror”, will reappear as Spock’s father, Sarek.

Verdict


In all seriousness, daft dialogue to one side, what’s not to like? I don’t kid myself that we all like the episodes that we like for the same reasons, but I think “Amok Time” is pretty great, even allowing for the faults with dialogue that I’ve already mentioned. It as the archetypal Star Trek hand to hand combat scene, with the fight between Kirk and Spock. It fills in a little background on the most consistently interesting member of the Enterprise crew, without necessarily totally deunding him of mystery. Where, for example, are his family while this ceremony is going on? Does he in fact have any family members still on Vulcan? These are questions which will be answered later on in the season, but for now it’s enough that the viewer asks the questions in the first place.

Not enough? Well, I also like the little more depth that is added to the understated Nurse Chapel/Spock unrequited love story. Spock, it appears does not reject Christine because he is totally unfeeling towards her, but because his biology means that he cannot love her, or at least not in any way which would satisfy her.

It’s not quite my favourite episode of the whole season, but I have to say, it’s right up there with the best of them.